In 2006 there was an episode of Doctor Who in which David Tennant’s Tenth Doctor went undercover in a school in an effort to flush out a band of alien shapechangers. Featuring the return of Sarah Jane Smith and K9, as well as a guest appearance from Anthony Head and a straightforward, enjoyable plot, the episode was met with praise from pretty much everyone. Fans, newcomers and critics all seemed to like it a great deal.
In 2014 the premise was deemed worthy of repeating. Only
this time the Doctor was being played by Peter Capaldi and he wouldn’t be going
undercover as a teacher but as a caretaker. Also, he would mention that he was
going undercover quite a bit. Because that’s funny, apparently.
Going back to the premise of the Doctor trying to work
inconspicuously in a school wasn’t a bad idea. It’s a setup that presents
opportunities for situational comedy and, specific to this season, gentle
nudging of the Danny Pink and Clara Oswald relationship. Let’s not forget that
situational comedy revolving around adult relationships is where co-writer
Steven Moffat made his name in the nineties, and that Gareth Roberts had
previously had success writing Matt Smith’s Doctor in an environment where he
had to pass himself off as a standard human and that he has previously striven
to mark himself as the funny Doctor Who writer. They seemed like the ideal combo
for this scenario.
And for the first fifteen minutes they were. We started
with the always popular montage of unseen adventures. Capaldi was funny and odd
and detached while being easy to watch. Coleman did some of her best work and
finally made it seem as though Clara actually enjoys the time she spends with the Doctor, something her usual
sarcasm and eye-rolling doesn’t achieve. The idea of the Doctor working at the
school was introduced well, as was a well-made monster prop (shot effectively
too, for the record).
But it couldn’t last. Around fifteen minutes into the
episode the Doctor sent the monster he was there to fight into the future,
leaving the episode to focus on Clara’s relationships with the Doctor and Danny
and the initial reactions of the two men to one another until it returned for
the Action Packed Final Sequence™. These relationship scenes were clearly what
the episode existed for, and that was fine. The Clara and Danny relationship is
clearly going to play a significant role in series eight as a whole and it was
a good decision to dedicate the bulk of an episode to establishing that the
Doctor and Danny do not initially like one another.
What let the episode down was… well, everything really.
The writing, the performances and the direction all seemed off. The trouble
with the latter is a straightforward complaint: too many shots looking up at
people’s faces as they mooched along corridors and an overuse of slow motion
effects. The writing and the performance troubles are broader. Clara spent the
entire episode essentially worrying about pleasing two men. Not a very 2014
mentality. And Danny, well Danny requires a paragraph all his own.
Danny revealed a previously unhinted at loathing of the
officer class (and some nifty acrobatics for that matter – seriously, what was
his somersaulting all about?) and came across as a controlling, emotionally
manipulative spouse in the scenes in which he and Clara were alone. Samuel
Anderson didn’t have the ability to make Danny seem likeable during these
scenes. They were unpleasant to watch and they shouldn’t have been. Unless, of
course, Moffat’s taking the show in a bold new direction and actually intends
to make Danny the controlling spouse he appeared to be here. If so then I’ll
take back what I’ve written about Anderson here because he nailed it. But I’ll
have a fresh batch of complaints about Moffat’s writing instead.
The saving grace was once again Capaldi. When his Doctor
was given funny lines Capaldi was funny and he was nicely believable during his
angry scenes with Danny. His Doctor is at his best when being given the chance
to be flippant and angry, so he was in his element. I wouldn’t mind Gareth
Roberts being given another episode next year, but ideally one without Moffat’s
relationship scenes slipped into them.
I thought the Danny scenes were building to the cheap revelation that "we're not so different, you and I". That may still be coming.
ReplyDeleteThe PCSO was doing some "classic who" style acting, all big and as though he was performing for stage not screen (as opposed to Danny who is performing for minimalists), in fact the acting was poorer than it has been in ages.
Just a thought, did they write Danny as a former soldier after they cast someone who couldn't convey emotion on screen? It's a thought.....
I imagine Danny was always a soldier considering the arc and the soldier comments that have featured so far. Building to the revelation is possible but I'm sure there was a scene with him saying he'd leave Clara after the mutual acceptance scene. So probs not.
Delete